Quote:
Originally Posted by
taa4j6
โก๏ธ
what tape does :
- give a certain frequency response (EQing)
- add some harmonics (distortion)
- slightly compress the sound (compression)
i don't like these tape sim plugs. i'd rather EQ, distort and compress myself with separate plugs, instead of using a so called "magic" plugin.
if you want a real tape sound, you have to record on tape first. going from DA to tape to AD is a bit pointless to me. you'll still get something digital sounding, unless the tape machine is really messed up and sounds like a dictaphone.
i don't think Cytomic is working on a tape sim.
Spot on bruvva! I'm not working on a tape sim plugin. Before I would even consider such a project I would have to be convinced that the "magic" of tape is preserved by the signal chain mic -> pre -> adc -> dac -> tape -> adc, as this is exactly the situation the plugin is in. I have a feeling that with really good converters and a high sample rate that it may be possible, but it would require lots of investigation and research.
If I did do a tape simulation it would be just that, a simulation of the magnetic fields, electronics, and physics of reality, not a conglomerate of existing dsp to approximate the same output results - that's just the way I swing. I find it easier to model what is going on and the structure it is done in and just use the final sound as a way of double checking things are right, not as the thing to be directly emulated itself. In that regard there would be no way to split apart the saturation from the compression from the frequency response, as it would all just be a result of the simulation. This is the case for The Glue as well, I can't split the compression from the saturation harmonics or vice versa, they are both the same thing and result from the simulation of the circuit.
I am not working on a pre-amp plugin either. Again it is something I would have to do lots of research into to be convinced such a plugin would be worthwhile. When you plug a mic or instrument into a pre-amp it becomes one circuit and the sound you get depends on both source and the pre-amp. There are some pre-amps that sound great with certain mics and not with others. I have a gut feeling that it is the joining of the two parts that counts, and splitting one from the other will have already lost lots of what is good. This will especially be the case if you want to save money on a decent pre by running your mic directly into a soundcard pre and then trying to "tone up" the signal with a plugin - it just won't give the same results at all.
That being said, if you do get good results from running a signal through the chain dac -> preamp -> adc, then I think a plugin could do justice to that. I feel there are currently better projects for me to concentrate on that are easier to tackle and will deliver better results.