Quote:
Originally Posted by
Philter
β‘οΈ
You should probably update that to just show native right? I mean, you're telling another guy that there's no demand for DSP hardware out there... but you're still prominently advertising it.
.
If my clientele was coming through the website I would deal with it, but they aren't and we're too busy to fit in any freelancers outside of us at this time. The whole website will be redone when the new studio is done.
As far as I'm concerned, Avid get's to determine what HD means. And it doesn't mean DSP. TDM and HDX are the names for the DSP systems, if a freelancer isn't aware of what they need that's really their issue. Is pschyomonkey required to disclose the RTL of his headphone system? Caveat Emptor.
As for discerning clients, I don't see that anymore with DSP either. I just had a band (Imperial Teen) in where 2 of the members were originally in Faith No More...so they've done tape, PT+LFAC in the past in high level environments. They are all working on native systems at home, our session went off without a hitch, nobody asked or cared about DSP. I have a bunch of the Hamilton touring company coming in for sessions while they are here, DSP is simply not coming up.
Frankly I don't get the justification for sub 3ms monitoring for bands. A drummer, has never once in his life experienced a snare drum with less than 2-3ms of latency as his ears are 2-3ft from the drum and the speed of sound is 1.1ms per foot. An analog foldback of a close mic snare will actually hit the drummers ears BEFORE the acoustic signal...Back in the day DSP made more sense purely because you couldn't reliably track with a 32 or 64 sample buffer- that's not true anymore.
Also these are the sample latencies of a bunch of AAX-DSP plugins-
AVID:
Channel Strip = 10
EQ3 = 10
Pultec = 10
All BF = 10
Dyn 3 = 10
Fairchild = 10
Impact = 10
Pro Comp = 10
Pro Exp = 10
Mod Delay = 10
Real Tape delay = 10
RectiFi = 10
Real Tape Sat = 10
SciFi = 10
purple 77 = 13
Smack = 11
Pro Multiband = 34
Pro Limiter = 73
Gray Comp = 34
Black Spring = 66
Dverb = 34
Reverb One = 66
Revibe = 66
Space = 66
Studio Reverb = 66
Tape Echo = 66
SansAmp = 63
Black shiny Wah = 34
C1, Flanger, Orange Phasor, Vibe Phasor = 66
Real Tape Flanger = 4811 !!!!!
Roto Speaker = 34
Distortion Pedals (all) = 66
Pro Subharmonic = 394
METRIC HALO
Channel Strip = 10
SOFTUBE
Summit EQ = 34
Summit Grand Ch = 38
Tube Tech Classic Ch = 38
Tube tech pultecs = 42
FET Comp = 34
From a fellow source I have talked with about this...
PLUGIN-ALLIANCE
XLA-3 = 76
BX Limiter = 348
Refinement = 76
Saturation V2 = 56
All Elysias = 76
SPL PassEq = 60
SPL Vitalizer = 60
VSM-3 = 76
All others are 34.
Many (most) of these same plugins are 0 samples in native land. If we are talking about monitoring through a relatively basic mix, with inserts of say gate, comp, eq bussed to an aux and a few color compressors here and there, it's very easy for HDX to end up with a comparable RTL to a state of the art native system in the real world, or have limited functionality in comparison.
I have spoken to many freelancers in my target price range for the new space (150-300/day for the studio, which is scalable), many of whom are only doing bands, and not one of them were worried about an HDX system. Additionally in my area only the older studios are running DSP rigs- the places doing the most bands, which are newer more mid priced places (around 50/hr here) are all native (though many advertise HD software).
I certainly can't say that this info applies to everyone out there, this is simply where I'm coming from having just done a fair amount of research into my market. I respect that PM is in a different realm of expectations (and prices), and his input is always very interesting to me, and I respect that there is a lot of different niches/avenues in this biz and respect your position as well...
But that all said I find it highly unlikely that the OP could finance a DSP rig, add it to his website, and have that be the silver bullet that shoots his bookings through the roof. Maybe I'm wrong...hell maybe I'll end up getting a HDX card at some point to accommodate people who are asking for it- but at this point I doubt it unless there is a massive shift in the development of dedicated DSP chips vs intel/amd.