Just wanted to share if anyone's interested. Here's my experience so far:
I had heard of MidiQuest for ages, and after reading commentary on v11 (on Gearslutz and elsewhere) I wasn't too thrilled and ended up using another vendor's editors for a handful of instruments for a long time through BlueCat Patchworks in Pro Tools. It worked well and stable, but was an absolute nightmare to map automation CCs through a middle man plugin because those editors weren't native AAX.
Just last week I saw this post that v12 had released and looking at the release notes I saw SoundQuest added AAX support in the latest version so I plunked down the $400 for the version that supported generated plugins.
So it took me a few days to read through the documentation and get the jist of the layout and design, but after settings up my MIDI devices and generating the plugins (took me a few tries, but luckily generating new plugin builds was very easy) this software is fantastic!
Not only instruments, but it controls a lot of effects units I have with MIDI functionaility too.
So far I have the following devices set up and working with MidiQuest 12 on Pro Tools (and occasionally Logic Pro X):
- Access Virus C/Indigo2
- Korg Prophecy
- Behringer DeepMind 12D
- Roland JP-8080
- Alesis Quadraverb
- Roland DEP-3
- Roland JV-1080
- Clavia Nord Lead (1)
- Novation MiniNova
- Novation Bass Station II
If you end up purchasing my advice would be to first (if on a Mac) go to macOS's Audio MIDI Setup utility and name your MIDI devices, then open up the standalone MidiQuest 12 program to set up your instruments and build out any plugins you need generated (only build them out after you've set up MIDI port and channel info, otherwise, stuff isn't going to work), then generate them. If you have a single MIDI interface like on an audio interface or a USB adapter, you'll probably have a bad time with the plugins. I have two MOTU Midi Express 128 devices I have everything running through so device ports never change.
One thing I'm still wrapping my head around is the librarian functionality. It's a bit different from other editor/librarians I've used before. Currently for brevity I'm sending my SysEx patches using SysEx Librarian at the start of projects and then relying on the instant recall functionality of the plugins in the DAW project to load in the modified performances and patches.
The demo is kind of limited, I was limited to only automate 4 knobs and I couldn't test the plugin functionality as far as I could tell. That said, I'm up and running with the other devices without much problem.
It's a super deep program, it's probably the first time I opened up software and had to immediately go to the documentation. I've seen complaints that the gui looks old, but it feels alright to me. I've had a lot of these devices for years, but it feels like I've only truly started learning them in and out in the past week with MidiQuest 12.
I hate gambling on software, but this gamble definitely paid off. I'm extremely happy with MidiQuest 12.