Quote:
Originally Posted by
8BitCulprit
β‘οΈ
Wasn't asking that. I was asking people here out of curiosity.
At least it's got people talking about what genres they make.
A BPM has nothing to do with that, records crossing a huge void of styles and times use the same BPMS, Diana Ross and Dizzy Rascal share some, hardly the same cookie cutter style as each other though.
I don't have a problem with people discussing tempos and genre. My rant wasn't totally related to the thread. What I do have a problem with is very specific genre or trying to write a track from a recipe... Hey I do acid techno, I set my DAW to 130bpm and whip out a sweet pattern on my 303 to go with my 4 on the floor 909 and maybe add some kind of crazy lead sound. Same thing happened for lots of genres that have come and gone... I have a hard time understanding how people working with so much freedom with their tools end up boxing themselves into very specific genres. Starting with set sounds, key, bpm and a rough idea of how they'll mix it seems like a backwards way to approach music especially when the tools used to make it allow to easily change as you go.
You wouldn't get a guitarist telling a drummer to start playing a 16-beat at 140 and tell the tech to hand him his detuned stratocaster patched into a cheap distortion box and hand him an sm57 for vocals because he wants to compose some 90's east-Seatle noisy rock music. Usually you'd start from a melody, a groove or some lyrics and everything else should set itself into place. I don' want to compare electronic music to rock music here. The same can totally be done in electronic music. You start playing on a keyboard, you end up with a sweet bass line. You could try forcing into 128bpm and change the key so the bass is phatter... or just go with it, maybe that bass line really sounds groovy at 100bpm...
Obviously not everyone works that way but I always find it very odd when people starting talking about ever more obscure genres and the way you should produce it rather than than coming up with a song and then trying to find a way to describe it, if need be.