Quote:
Originally Posted by
Monotremata
β‘οΈ
You've made a generative sequencer, not a modular synth..
Logic sure cant do what this can on its own..

I know I'm late to the party, but this post by "Monotremata" really annoys me.
First off, it's wrong in the very real sense of claiming something that is untrue.
Secondly, it is condescending since the author never bothered to actually check what the OP was doing.
Valli actually made a modular synth using the programmability of Logic, the Midi routing and the scripting language.
From Wikipedia: Modular synthesizers are synthesizers composed of separate modules for different functions. The modules can be connected together by the user to create a patch. The outputs from the modules may include audio signals, analog control voltages, or digital signals for logic or timing conditions. Typical modules are voltage-controlled oscillators, voltage-controlled filters, voltage-controlled amplifiers and envelope generators.
Valli uses MIDI values instead of CV voltages, which amounts to the same thing, since there are no voltages in a digital incarnation. He uses these digital CV's to du exactly what the definition states needs doing to qualify.
So what's your beef with Valli, Monotremata?
Are you so narrow minded that you want to put him down because he doesn't have a metal box with knobs and patch cables, but instead choses the much more environmentally friendly digital cables and digital knobs and switches?
It is so disheartening to read a so negative set of responses on this forum. You and people like you made Valli retract his whole project from the public domain because he felt attacked and hurt by the ignorance and bile poured at him.
I hope you're satisfied and that your ego is gratified!