Quote:
Originally Posted by
nksoloproject
➡️
So is a GoPro a good choice for filming a band, then? I'm torn between the Go Pro Hero8 or the Zoom QN2 4k.
GoPro pros:
Wide angle, 4k. Easy to get the whole band in, in a small room, and the 4k gives you four HD cameras worth of data, meaning you can zoom in 4x and still have HD pixel density. Since bands play on single level stages, this isn't strictly true in practice, but you can zoom further with 4k than HD before pixellation is as noticable.
GoPro cons:
Battery life, SD card capacity, necessary placement due to wide angle, necessary accessories.
At maxed video and audio settings (RAW audio) i got around 45 minutes before the battery died. I get about an hour with standard audio recordings. I don't even use the onboard audio, so no loss there.
With a 10 Ah external battery, I get about 90 minutes of recording time before the internal battery goes dead. The charge limiting circuitry does not keep up with the discharge rate.
You need big SD cards. 256GB or larger, and they do not swap quickly.
To full frame a typical band, the tripod needs to be around 6-8 feet back from the lead vox mic stand. On an SL-100 stage setup, up against JBL 828 subs (vibration) and out in the "dance floor" area. Big gigs get tripods kicked or moved out of adjustment.
Accessories, you don't get a standard 1/4" by 20 tripod adaptor. $6. You need extra batteries. $20-30 each. An extra charger, $40. Extra SD cards, $40. A "trap door" battery cover, if you plan to use external batteries. $20. The front element of the lense and touch screen are no longer replaceable, and need protection. $10-20. You can save some money here, IF you run a fleet of GoPros instead of just one.
As for lighting... anything besides a tuned lightshow will lower video quality. Ideally, you want mostly white or pastel front washes, properly dimmed to match camera exposure levels, then a back line show with commensurate brightness to match the front washes.
Limited exposure ranges will tend to make all but the very front audience rows dusapoear into darkness unless the backline blinders are on.
The lower the level of light you work with, the grainier your video will be, and less expensive sensors get grainy fast in low light.
HDMI capture cards start around $100, but this level is marginal. Magewells go $300-400, offer better performance, and can drive an HDMI cable over longer distance without freezing. Past 25 feet, HDMI gets iffy, unless you use... the right... HDMI to Cat 5 systems. Trial and error there.
Black Magic's ATEM minis offer a control surface and three HDMI inputs for about the price of a Magewell capture card, but I haven't used them and can't comment on quality or reliable operation.
At pro levels, video travels over SDI.